Mattress toppers are generally 2 - 4 inch layers of foam (or other materials) placed on top of a mattress to increase the softness or comfort of the bed.

Instead of buying a new mattress, some people would prefer to just buy a new topper to save money. A mattress topper would cost around $20-$150 while the cheapest mattress would be around $250, with better quality beds costing much more.

Memory foam mattresses are among the most expensive, especially with premium brands like Tempurpedic.

Therefore, if your mattress has some wear under its belt and you are thinking about buying a new one or finding some comfort then you may be having the memory foam mattress vs. topper debate that so many do. 

Is it worth it to spend a little bit on a band-aid solution like a topper or should you just dive in and buy a new mattress

Let's see if we can help...

Advantages of using mattress toppers

Mattress toppers are made from different types of materials. If your mattress is made of memory foam, then you can also consider buying memory foam toppers. You can place them on top of the mattress and it will feel as if you are sleeping on a new mattress. It can also be as comfortable as a new mattress. It is way cheaper too.

Over time, mattresses sag and impressions are left. This is just normal even for mattresses made from high quality materials. With constant use, these problems would really happen. If you wish to change your mattress, but you are on a tight budget, then a mattress topper would already suffice.

When not to use toppers

Mattress toppers can only be used if there is an issue on the surface of the bed. If the problem is the structure, then it has to be replaced. Even if a topper is placed on the top portion of the mattress, it won’t be enough to fix the problem.

For instance, spring failures or the hammock effect won’t be prevented by using a topper. In fact, you are providing a solution that does not necessarily work thinking that everything can be solved by a new topper. If the foundation of the bed is really damaged or there are spring issues, then it has to be replaced.

Buying a new mattress

When you have realized that the mattress topper won’t do the job, you might start thinking about a new memory foam mattress. Obviously, you would have to spend a lot to bring one home.

Even those that are sold online come with a high price tag. Before closing your doors on this idea, you need to understand that you are investing on an item that can last for the next 7 years or more, therefore, it is still a great deal after all. Besides, the old and non-functional mattress can be sold in junk shops or recycling shops and you can still get money out of it.

Another reason why you should invest on a new mattress is that it can enhance airflow when you sleep.

This is something that can’t be solved by simply using a topper. The problem with toppers is that they are placed on top of the actual mattresses.

Therefore, there is no proper airflow. It is not ideal for overnight use especially during the summer. If you are searching for a way to solve your problem regarding comfort when sleeping, toppers won’t do the trick.

Avoid Overspending on a Mattress

If you have decided to go for a new memory foam mattress instead of a topper, you are confronted with a problem regarding the price.

Luxury memory foam mattresses would cost thousands of dollars. The best solution is to go for a brand new mid-range mattress. Another option is to go for a bargain memory foam mattress. The problem with this option is that it won’t last long. It has to be replaced again after 5 years. If you have to spend money by that time, then it is better to go for a mid-range mattress instead. It is durable and will most likely last for over 10 years.

To top it all, you need to stick with high quality and trusted brands. Since you are spending money to buy a new one, you need to make sure that you bring home something that would solve your back pains and provide you with a comfortable sleep at night.

The same thing is true even if you have decided to just buy a topper instead. You need to find high quality toppers that you won’t regret buying.

In the end, deciding between a new memory foam mattress or a mattress topper is a tough call. The key is to analyze the problem with your current mattress first to determine the best option.